2022 Pac-12 Football Previews: QB Play Key for Colorado

Brendon Lewis is fresh off his first season as the starter, engineering a rocky 4-8 campaign

Posted on June 6, 2022


  By Dane Miller, SuperWest Sports

This Colorado preseason football preview is the first of 12 to appear over as many weeks as we count down the days to the start of the Pac-12 season on September 1st.

Pac-12Each preview consists of nine sections: OverviewBest-Case ScenarioWorst-Case ScenarioWhat Should HappenWhat Must HappenGreatest StrengthBiggest ConcernDeciding Factors, and Schedule Analysis.

Nothing is set in stone, however, as rosters and depth charts continue to evolve over the summer.

Colorado Buffaloes Fast Facts

2021 Record: 4-8
Head Coach: Karl Dorrell (8-10 in two years at Colorado)
Offensive Coordinator: Mike Sanford
Defensive Coordinator: Chris Willson
Home Stadium: Folsom Field (50,183), Boulder, CO
Last Conference Title: 2001, Big 12


Overview
The success of Colorado’s 2022 season, and perhaps the tenure of Karl Dorrell, will likely be determined by the play of its quarterback.

Brendon Lewis is fresh off his first season as the starter, engineering a rocky 4-8 campaign while leading one of the nation’s worst offenses.

Behind him, J.T. Shrout is the second option in Boulder, after missing all of last year due to a knee injury sustained during fall camp.

Whichever player ends up as the starter will have to contend with a roster decimated by the transfer portal.

Colorado QB Brendon Lewis | CUBuffs.com

Offensive starters Jarek Broussard, Brenden Rice, and Dimitri Stanley are all gone, while defensive starters Mekhi Blackmon, Christian Gonzalez, and Mark Perry left too.

Compounded with the graduation of Carson Wells and Nate Landman, the defensive strength that CU has enjoyed over the past handful of seasons is suddenly in question.

And with the departures of several key offensive contributors from a unit that already struggled mightily, Colorado may struggle to reach three wins.


Best-Case Scenario
Lewis makes a significant jump from last year to lead the Buffs to bowl eligibility.

The sophomore improved as the year went on, getting comfortable within the offense and guiding CU to late-season victories over Oregon State and Washington.

With the natural talent and size to be one of the top quarterbacks in the Pac-12, decision-making and play-calling will have an oversized impact on his success.

His scrambling ability and willingness to run are strengths that he should exploit, which could help improve the traditional ground game by opening lanes for his backs.

Alex Fontenot | Tim Benko/Colorado Athletics

Enter Alex Fontenot.

Arguably short-shifted behind Broussard and Ashaad Clayton, the time for Fontenot to shine is now. A capable pass-catcher out of the backfield, the senior has all the tools to exceed as the No. 1 running back.

If Fontenot can average four to five yards per carry behind an improved Lewis, the Colorado offense should regain the red zone efficiency it had a few seasons ago, with tight end Brady Russell and Baylor wide receiver transfer R.J. Sneed reaping the benefits.


Worst Case Scenario
The transfers at the offensive and defensive skill positions, along with the graduation of its linebacker corps, are too much to overcome, resulting in a one-win season.

The heart and soul of the Colorado ‘D,’ Wells and Landman exhausted their eligibility, leaving a gaping hole at linebacker.

Mix in the departures of three experienced defensive backs in Blackmon, Gonzalez, and Perry, and it’s fair to say the CU defense is a major cause for concern.

Where will the leadership and production come from?

Terrance Lang | Chip Bromfield/ProMotion Ltd.

Defensive lineman Terrance Lang, linebacker Quinn Perry, and West Virginia linebacker transfer Josh Chandler-Semedo are probably the top players on that side of the ball and the obvious answers.

But their ability to impact the game might not compare to the All-Conference LBs that Dorrell lost.

The result could be a team that gives up too many points and doesn’t have the offensive firepower to win shootouts.

And if that happens, the local Colorado media might be publishing stories about the terms of Dorrell’s buy-out by the end of the season.


What Should Happen
Lewis or Shrout emerge from Fall Camp as the clear starter and leader of the program.

The confidence gained from securing the starting job is on full display in the opener, as the Buffs upset TCU on Folsom Field.

The momentum continues into Week Two with a road victory over Air Force and holds steady into the early part of the Conference season with wins over Arizona and California.

The Buffs travel to Air Force in Week 2 | Chancey Bush/The Gazette

The remainder of the year features a string of tough defeats, with the matchups against Arizona State and Washington coming down to the wire.

The end result is a four-win season with the 2023 campaign becoming Dorrell’s make-or-break year.


What Must Happen
The defense has to make up for the production it lost over the offseason.

Blackmon and Gonzalez were among the top defensive backs in the league, while Landman and Wells were widely considered to be elite LBs in the Pac-12.

The inexperience in the secondary must be overcome quickly, or the Buffs won’t win many games.

Chandler-Semedo must generate production in the second level, while Lang needs to wreak havoc up front.

West Virginia transfer Josh Chandler-Semedo | USA TODAY Sports

At the same time, Dorrell’s offense can’t go through another season of just 18.8 points per game. An improved ground game is pivotal, and Fontenot’s health could be a deciding factor.

Like a snowball rolling downhill, a better rushing attack will exponentially help Colorado’s quarterback do damage to a secondary focused on slowing down the run.

It’s not a chicken or the egg scenario: It all starts on the ground.


Greatest Strength
Without the traditional defensive strength that has become a hallmark of Colorado Football over the past handful of seasons, the Buffs’ greatest strength is nuanced.

After so many departures to the transfer portal, the players remaining in Boulder are those that actually want to be there.

The camaraderie such circumstances create should galvanize the roster, producing an “Us vs. Everyone” mentality that is worth its weight in gold.

Photo courtesy KKTV

The result should be a team that never quits and is able to battle back from deficits.

And while team chemistry and hard work don’t always translate to wins, it should keep the locker room morale high enough to produce an upset victory or two during the 2022 season.


Biggest Concern
The inexperience in the secondary is a substantial problem Dorrell faces heading into the year.

Chandler-Semedo was one of the top linebackers in the Big 12 and should fit nicely into the shoes that Landman left. Production from fellow LB Perry is a given.

Colorado’s defensive depth is a big concern | Devin Marquez/cubuffs.com

Yet, the Buffs lost three key defensive backs in Blackmon, Gonzalez, and Perry.

New blood must emerge at the corner and safety positions for Colorado to be competitive against Pac-12 offenses.


Deciding Factors
The Buffs’ season will arguably rise and fall on the play of its quarterback. Lewis has the potential to be a high-level QB in the Conference, but is incapable of leading his offense to points when he struggles.

The night-and-day nature of Lewis opens the door to Shrout, who could end up as the starter and never look back. Either way, the play of Colorado’s quarterback will likely change the trajectory of its season.

Outside of the gunslinger, the CU offensive line is probably the second deciding factor in the third season under Dorrell.

CU offensive lineman Casey Roddick | Tim Benko/Benko Photographics

The offense only managed to put up 257 yards per game in 2021, arguably hampered by an O-Line that ranked 11th in the Pac-12 in sacks allowed (2.67 per game).

The struggles up front resulted in one of the worst third-down conversion percentages in the nation, with Colorado managing to convert just 32.3 percent of the time (119th out of 130 FBS teams).

Alabama transfer Tommy Brown has been added to the mix up front, but the Buffs lost senior lineman Chance Lytle to the portal.


Schedule Analysis
2022 Colorado Buffaloes Schedule

Sept. 2 vs TCU
Sept. 1o at Air Force
Sept. 17 at Minnesota
Sept. 24 vs UCLA
Oct. 1 at Arizona
Oct. 15 vs California
Oct. 22 at Oregon State
Oct. 29 vs Arizona State
Nov. 5 vs Oregon
Nov. 11 at USC
Nov. 19 at Washington
Nov. 26 vs Utah

The year opens with an opportunity against a reloaded Big 12 team.

TCU struggled against California at home last year, but has a Top 30 recruiting class and the No. 12 transfer class, according to 247Sports.

That might spell trouble for Colorado, yet the advantage of playing at home could result in a surprise victory over the Horned Frogs.

The second game of the year features a road test at Air Force. The run-heavy option attack is hard to defend, but CU should come out on top.

Yet, a 0-2 start to the year wouldn’t be much of a shock.

And it doesn’t get any easier with another road game in Week Three, this time at Minnesota.

CU visits Minnesota in Week 3 | Ron Chenoy/USA TODAY Sports

With that slate on deck, a 1-2 nonconference season is probably the most that can be expected.

Over the remaining nine games of Pac-12 play, winnable matchups are few and far between. The showdowns with Arizona, California, and Washington are realistic opportunities for wins.

While the games against Arizona State and Oregon State are longer shots.

And while upsets happen, the contests with UCLA, Oregon, USC, and Utah all likely end with a defeat.

With all that in mind, the ceiling for Colorado in 2022 appears to be five wins with a floor of just a single victory. The result is probably somewhere in between, with three Ws emerging as the safest bet.




—More from Dane Miller—