
By Stephen Vilardo, SuperWest Sports
June 18, 2025
This was probably the most difficult position group to narrow down to the Top 12.
The wealth of talent at the position in our region will spark plenty of debate about who was left off.
Today, as we continue to gear up for the 2025 college football season, we look at the best QBs in the West.
1. Sam Leavitt, Arizona State

He posted a 4-1 last season against ranked opponents, throwing 24 TDs and just six interceptions, with the lone loss coming to Texas in the overtime thriller in the playoffs.
While Cam Skattebo will be gone, ASU brings back a slew of talented receivers. Leavitt can also make plays with his legs and is sneaky good at evading tacklers.
2. Nico Iamaleava, UCLA

He was expected to be a star at Tennessee, and had fine numbers last season, throwing for 2,616 yards and 19 TDs while leading the Vols to the playoffs.
His former UT squad relied on their defense and ground game; with the Bruins this fall, the signal caller will need to put all of his potential into production, and I think he will make that happen.
3. Jake Retzlaff, BYU

On the field he can spin it and has a slew of weapons returning at his disposal.
Like it or not, if Retzlaff is on the field with his head in the right space and the talent that surrounds him, BYU could be a Playoff threat.
4. Demond Williams Jr., Washington

The first part of last season was spent backing up Will Rogers, before emerging as a starter against Oregon. He provided a spark whenever he got on the field.
Williams is a good athlete who can beat you with the run, but his accuracy should be what jumps out at you this season.
5. Dante Moore, Oregon

During that season he showed signs of brilliance but also played like the freshman he was with nine interceptions in nine games.
The talent is certainly there, and the last two transfers the Ducks brought in under Will Stein worked out pretty well.
6. Noah Fifita, Arizona

This season we should see better play than last year when the Wildcats offense, and entire team as a whole, was a bit underwhelming. He will not have Tetairoa McMillan on the outside, but the sum of the WR parts might be more efficient than the group from last season.
The line was terrible in 2024, and it had an impact on the QB’s accuracy as he dipped to completing just 60.5% of his throws. That number should be much better this year.
7. Devon Dampier, Utah

At New Mexico, Dampier completed just 57.9% of his passes. That will need to get better. His ability to run the ball could fit in perfectly as the Utes need to get more physical, especially running the ball.
His passing numbers should improve, and the 12 interceptions should drop (they need to) but when games were on the line last season at UNM, Dampier made plays.
8. Maddux Madsen, Boise State

He threw just six interceptions while connecting on 23 TDs and over 3,000 yards through the air as he led Boise State to a playoff appearance.
With Jeanty gone, more of the production will fall to Madsen this season. The offense may need more out of him, but there is no reason to doubt he will produce what is needed.
9. Jayden Maiava, USC

USC went 3-1 during that stretch, and while his numbers were not eye-popping, the results were good.
For all of their struggles in 2024, the Trojans still led the Big Ten in passing. Maiava should be productive this fall.
10. Maalik Murphy, Oregon State

In his one season in Durham, he threw for 2,933 yards with 26 TDs and 12 interceptions. The Beavers will need him to cut down on the interception total, but they should get good numbers from Murphy.
A bit overlooked in the most recent transfer period, he may have a chip on his shoulder as he looks to erase any doubts about his ability in 2025.
11. Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi, Colorado State

He threw for 2,796 yards with 14 touchdowns and nine interceptions. That was a dip from his freshmen season in which he threw for 3,460 with 22 TDs but 16 interceptions.
A deeper look at the numbers shows the completion percentage was similar. But injuries also limited the Rams pass catchers last season. Look for a bounce back season for the QB in 2025.
12. E.J. Warner, Fresno State

He also had 13 interceptions, and that number needs to improve for the Bulldogs this season. The son of former NFL star Kurt Warner has been a starter since his freshmen season, wherever he has been.
Warner’s experience will bode well for a Fresno team looking to fill a lot of holes.
Other Notables
• Walker Eget, San Jose State
• Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele, Cal
• Micah Alejado, Hawai’i
• Kaidon Salter, Colorado
• Anthony Colandrea, UNLV
• Bryson Barnes, Utah State
-
Ranking the Top College Football Quarterbacks in the West
> The best players who are expected to play at the position for the region's programs in 2025 - June 18, 2025 -
Ranking the Top College Football Running Backs in the West
> The best players who are expected to play at the position for the region's programs in 2025 - June 17, 2025 -
Ranking the Top College Football Wide Receivers in the West
> The best players who are expected to play at the position for the region's programs in 2025 - June 12, 2025